Why did Lee Buck Arch?

12 piece bucket
Assumption: Lee Buck had a 10-2-D grip.

SO

Per Mr. K's thoughts on 10-2-D: Very compatible with the Cut Shot procedures. Any Left Wrist Bend at Impact Fix should be maintained throughout the Stroke.

and

4-A-3 ARCHED The Wrist is ARCHED when the Hand is bent forward - or inward - “rounding off” the forearm. A small amount is advisable and very useful (as insurance against 4-A-2 above and as amplification of Clubhead Lag) if its Push Shot tendency is properly compensated.

10-18-0 GENERAL Wrist Action is classified according to changes in Left Wrist Position prior to Impact. The Backstroke Positions are “Turned” and/or “Cocked.” The Downstroke Positions are “Rolled” and/or “Uncocked” (Chapter 4). But never “Bent” or “Arched” except with 10-2-C, 10-2-D or Variation “B” below. So the possible Positions - in both directions - can be - the one - or the other - or both - or neither of the alternatives. Seven Actions are listed below. Comply with 6-B-3-0-1 and 6-C-2-A. All Wrist Action is subject to the requirements of Loading and of Grip Types.

If 10-2-D is ALREADY compatible with Cut Shots, why did Lee Buck ARCH? More No HOOK INSURANCE?
galopin
1. "No-hook" insurance, as you wrote;
2. "No-flip" (prevent a Bent Left Wrist) insurance;
3. To move his Low Point ahead of his Left Shoulder.

It would be interesting to hear other explanations.
EC
Bucket,

Hit a million balls off REALLY, REALLY, REALLY hard, thin turf in VERY, VERY, VERY windy conditions and check out your left wrist impact condition.

EC
12 piece bucket
Originally Posted by TGMfan Did he arch? His wrist looks pretty flat at Impact to me in this sequence.

http://asafgolf.free.fr/images/golf/...evino_face.jpg
Hmm. . . does look more flat. Notice a couple of things. Compare the address wrist condition to impact. Also looks pretty Arched at the Top.

However, 10-2-D says that the Wrist Bend should be there at Impact. We could argue whether it's Arched at Impact, but it is at the very least FLAT. This is not the prescribed 'degree' of bend for 10-2-D.

Thanks for posting the sequence!
12 piece bucket
Originally Posted by EC Bucket,

Hit a million balls off REALLY, REALLY, REALLY hard, thin turf in VERY, VERY, VERY windy conditions and check out your left wrist impact condition.

EC
Really got it from the dirt huh? Good point . . . as always!
TGMfan
Originally Posted by 12 piece bucket However, 10-2-D says that the Wrist Bend should be there at Impact. We could argue whether it's Arched at Impact, but it is at the very least FLAT. This is not the prescribed 'degree' of bend for 10-2-D.
Bucket,

As you quoted in your original post, any bend at Impact Fix should also be present at Impact. He doesn't start from Impact Fix, though - if he did, it'd probably look exactly like Impact!
12 piece bucket
Originally Posted by TGMfan Bucket,

As you quoted in your original post, any bend at Impact Fix should also be present at Impact. He doesn't start from Impact Fix, though - if he did, it'd probably look exactly like Impact!
You got me! Not really a Fix address is it? Do you have any down the line sequences? I'm looking at the one in a book called The Methods of Golf's Masters. He's definitely Arched at Start Down. Hard to tell if the Arched condition is maintained all the way down and through.