yoda's putting sequence

can anyone give a explantation for yoda's set up in his putting stance. I am a teaching professional and I would have a very hard time promoting that set up to a student.

Thanks

I'm in between lessons-still waiting on a reply.

I'm no guru but have been trying out this putting pattern since visiting the swamp. Basically, the stance and setup are just like that of a full stroke. Right forarm on plane, extensor action, etc... The main differences from my regular setup are zeroing out accumulator #3 (ie. put the grip under the thumb pad instead of the heel pad), and the ball is more forward than usual for me (just behind lowpoint). It feels amazingly natural, and it works great for me...setup, stroke it, keep those hands movin', listen for the ball hitting the bottom of the cup.

Yoda outlined it in detail here:
http://www.lynnblakegolf.com/forum/s....php?t=2590&#2

What do you see that you don't really like nasty?

The "bent-overness"? Ball position?

Nasty,

Interesting handle.

Basically Yoda is making a putting stroke which complies with his primary swing pattern. In it, he sets up so the ball is struck at, or just prior to the low point of the swing, which is just opposite of his left shoulder. The left shoulder is the top of the swing radius rather than the spine. You will find that in nearly every swing, the left shoulder to clubhead distance defines the full radius at low point.

There are many styles of putting which are geometrically sound, one of the most common is a hands centered, shoulder rock with the arms and hands frozen. This puts the center of rotation around the spine and is also very effective. But why should someone have to change their stroke pattern when they walk up on the putting green? Why not use your primary stroke pattern with the flat stick?

Bagger

Keep in mind that Collards is weilding a 32 inch stick . Could have something to do with it.

Their are numerous problems I have with this putting set up. First, Yoda or a potential student will require back surgery at some point. Secondly, it appears that yoga has loaded up his weight on his left side, which seems like it would be very inconsistent (pressure putts). I'm not intending to write off the style, but a more traditional set up will stand the test of time.

Originally Posted by nasty213 Their are numerous problems I have with this putting set up. First, Yoda or a potential student will require back surgery at some point. Secondly, it appears that yoga has loaded up his weight on his left side, which seems like it would be very inconsistent (pressure putts). I'm not intending to write off the style, but a more traditional set up will stand the test of time.

What about Jack's set up? Problems there?

of course, I have very similar problems with Jack's, but keep in mind that Jack is a needle in the haystack. I never said the style couldn't or wouldn't work. I merely stated that it would be difficult to teach to the masses.

I am very fortunate to get to spend a good deal of time with David Toms who he is not to shabby with the flat stick. "weight centered, eyes over the ball and target line, path like a closing door."